British Prime Minister Keir Starmer staunchly defended his Treasury chief, Rachel Reeves, on Monday against fierce opposition claims that she intentionally misrepresented the state of the nation's public finances ahead of the recent budget announcement. Starmer categorically stated that there was “no misleading” in the run-up to the tax-raising budget presented by the Chancellor of the Exchequer. The government hopes this budget will generate revenue to reduce national borrowing, finance infrastructure projects and public services, ease pressure from the cost of living, and stimulate long-awaited economic growth, reports The WP Times with reference to the Associated Press.
Controversy Over Budget Forecasts and Election Promises
Three weeks before the budget was delivered, Reeves gave a major speech in which she prepared the public and financial markets for a potential hike in income tax rates—a move that would have directly violated a significant Labour election pledge. Following a backlash among governing Labour Party lawmakers and the subsequent release of a more favourable update on the public finances, the Chancellor opted to backtrack, choosing less severe revenue-generating measures instead. Opposition parties, including the Conservatives and the Scottish National Party (SNP), allege that Reeves was aware the forecast from the independent Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) was better than anticipated when she delivered her initial speech. Consequently, the Conservatives and the SNP have formally requested the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) to investigate Reeves's preliminary comments and alleged media leaks. Furthermore, Reform U.K. leader Nigel Farage has called upon the government’s standards adviser to probe the Chancellor’s statements.
Reeves maintains her innocence, denying all allegations of misleading the public or financial markets. On Sunday, she asserted that the OBR had indeed assessed, prior to the budget, that tax revenue would be £16 billion ($21 billion) less than previously projected due to a downgraded productivity forecast. Although this indicated a smaller budget shortfall than initially feared, critics implied the government had engaged in political manipulation. Reeves countered that her initial speech correctly stated that “the OBR downgrade has had a big impact on the public finances. And that was why I would need to ask people to contribute more.” The Labour government secured a landslide victory in July 2024 on a manifesto promise not to raise income taxes for working individuals. Despite this, some of the budget’s £26 billion ($34 billion) in tax increases, primarily intended to build up a fiscal buffer against future economic shocks, were seen as violating the spirit, if not the precise letter, of that key election promise.
Starmer Defends Decisions and Outlines Future Focus
Speaking at a community centre in London on Monday, Starmer forcefully defended his government’s actions, asserting that they had inherited “public finances and public services in total crisis” after 14 years of Conservative rule. He defended the tax rises, the increase in the minimum wage, and the funding allocated to public services aimed at reducing child poverty. Starmer declared: “We confronted reality, we took control of our future and Britain is now back on track. Bit by bit, you will see a country that no longer feels the burden of decline.”
Finally, Starmer outlined the government's dual focus on two potentially contentious tasks: reducing Britain’s rapidly growing welfare bill, which risks alienating some Labour members, and fostering a closer relationship with the European Union (EU), which is likely to provoke pro-Brexit politicians from the Conservative and Reform parties. He reiterated that the previous exit deal negotiated before the 2020 departure from the EU had "significantly hurt our economy" and that “We have to keep moving toward a closer relationship with the EU.”
Read about the life of Westminster and Pimlico district, London and the world. 24/7 news with fresh and useful updates on culture, business, technology and city life: France issues statement on peace talks ahead of meeting between Zelenskyy and Macron
